Applying
The UN desk review explained: how the evaluation criteria matrix actually scores your application
8 min read
The system
8 min read · updated 5 August 2026
A vacancy announcement states its grade as a fixed fact — P-3, G-5, D-1 — but that number is not arbitrary and it is not attached to the person who happens to hold the post. It is the output of a specific HR process called classification, which grades the job, not the jobholder. Understanding how classification works explains a few things that otherwise look strange from the outside: why two seemingly similar titles can sit at different grades, why a post can be reclassified without the person in it changing at all, and why doing more senior-sounding work does not, on its own, move your grade.
Classification measures the post, using standards maintained by the International Civil Service Commission (ICSC) — the same body that sets the salary scale covered in that guide. A classification exercise looks at factors like the scope and complexity of the work, the level of independent judgement required, the nature of supervision given and received, the knowledge and skills the function genuinely demands, and the post’s relationships and impact within the organization. None of this depends on who is sitting in the chair — a classification exercise is run against the written job description and the actual duties of the post, not the qualifications or seniority of a specific staff member.
Classification is normally carried out by dedicated classification specialists inside an organization’s HR function, applying the relevant ICSC master standard and function-specific standards rather than a hiring manager’s own judgement about how senior a role feels. The Professional and higher categories are classified against the common ICSC framework used across the P-to-USG ladder; General Service posts are classified against a separate standard, tied to the specific local labour market described in the GS category guide. A hiring manager drafts the job description and proposes a grade, but classification specialists confirm or adjust it against the standard before a post can be advertised at that grade.
Classification happens at two points in a post’s life. A new post is classified before it is ever advertised, so the grade on the vacancy announcement has already cleared this process. An existing post can also be reclassified later, usually because its actual duties have genuinely changed — new responsibilities added over time, a restructuring that shifted scope, or a function that has grown beyond its original grade in practice, not just on paper. A reclassification request is normally initiated by management, on the basis of the post’s evolved duties, and goes back through the same classification standard as a new post. It is a review of the job, and it can move a grade up or down depending on what the review actually finds — it is not a mechanism for rewarding an individual jobholder.
This is the distinction that trips candidates up most: classifying or reclassifying a post changes what grade that function is worth, while your own promotion and career progression is a separate process about your personal advancement through competitive selection into higher-graded posts. Taking on more senior duties informally, without the post itself being reclassified, does not raise your grade or your pay — it may be recognised through a Special Post Allowance for acting at a higher level, but that is a temporary allowance, not a change to the post’s classified grade. If your actual duties have expanded well beyond your post description, the accurate path is asking your manager to request a reclassification review, not assuming expanded duties translate into a higher grade automatically.
The grade on a vacancy announcement reflects a completed classification exercise, so it is a fixed input for that competition, not something negotiable during the hiring process the way a private-sector title or level sometimes is. If a role’s actual responsibilities look mismatched with its stated grade — either heavier or lighter than the number suggests — that is a classification question for the organization to revisit, not something an individual candidate can resolve by applying anyway at a grade the post was not classified for. Reading the grade alongside the full job description, rather than the title alone, gives the more accurate picture of what a specific post actually involves.
Every vacancy on the board lists its classified grade up front, and a free changemaker profile helps you track which grades you are a genuine, competitive fit for as you apply.
Related guides
Every vacancy in the system is on the board, and a page that carries your evidence takes minutes to start.